The Hidden Complexity of Clinical Supervision: Triangulation and Conflicts of Interest

In therapy, triangulation is one of the big problems. Whenever a therapist becomes drawn into the relational dynamics between a client and the people in their life, there is a risk of becoming triangulated; that is, they come to stand between the client and the people they live and interact with. This can happen unwittingly, even unknowingly. If a therapist starts working in individual sessions with people who know each other, this risk becomes more apparent: he-said-she-said can easily turn into the-therapist-said or you-know-how-they-are. The therapist may find themselves recruited into a conflict or positioned as an intermediary, rather than remaining focused on their therapeutic role.

Supervisors help therapists deal with such situations. We help the therapist recognize and avoid triangulation and other conflicts of interest, and, when these situations arise despite everyone’s best intentions, we help them understand and mitigate the consequences.

But the funny thing is: supervision almost always contains the potential for triangulation and conflicts of interest.

As a supervisor, I stand, by definition, in a relationship between the client and my supervisee, their therapist. Most of the time, this is no problem. If the therapist does their work well, if the client understands that their therapist is still learning and gives them the grace a learner may need, and if the supervisor asks enough questions to identify possible issues before they become problems, the arrangement works well. But if any one of those links breaks, the supervisor may have to become more directly involved. In certain circumstances, this might mean speaking with the client to help prevent escalation. In others, it may mean instructing the therapist, their supervisee, to take an action the client does not appreciate.

Furthermore, supervision, by definition, involves the supervisor taking responsibility for overseeing and evaluating aspects of the therapist’s work. Depending on the supervisory arrangement, the supervisor may need to report to a third party. In some situations, all that needs to be reported is that the therapist worked under supervision and for how long. In others, reports may be required detailing what was discussed in supervision and how the supervisee presented. Sometimes the supervisor may even need to make an assessment of the supervisee’s fitness to practise.

This is one of the reasons supervision is a trainable profession. I remember a time when, in Ontario at least, psychotherapy was not yet a regulated profession. Before 2015, there was no regulatory framework for psychotherapists comparable to the ones that existed for psychologists, nurses or social workers. Consequently, there were no profession-wide regulatory requirements for becoming a clinical supervisor of psychotherapists. If you had been practising for a number of years, you were often considered capable of supervising others. Back then, there was little formal preparation to help a new supervisor understand the subtle differences between being a great therapist and being a good supervisor.

The parallel I often draw is the difference between working with individuals and working with family systems. As an individual therapist, the client is the primary focus of the therapeutic relationship. A family or couples therapist, however, needs to hold the well-being of the whole system in view. They need to understand how each member of the system functions and how the relationships between them create the dynamics that need attention. This requires particular skills, which are developed through training and practice.

A supervisor works in a similar environment. Their attention is not only on the supervisee and their work. They need to understand the supervisee’s client, too, and the dynamics between the supervisee and their client, often without ever having met the client. Add to that the dynamics between supervisee and supervisor, and you have a complex system that needs to be navigated.

The supervisor is not outside this system, observing it objectively. They are part of it. Their own reactions, assumptions, expectations and use of authority can influence the supervisory relationship and, indirectly, the therapeutic work. This means that the supervisor needs to be aware not only of the dynamics between therapist and client, but also of their own participation in the supervisory process.

To many therapists who are considering becoming supervisors, this can seem like a daunting task. Together with the fear of responsibility and paperwork, it is a major reason why some hesitate to take the step into supervision. That is a pity, especially because many seasoned therapists already work with systems in the way described. We consider our clients’ families, relationships and broader environments when we work with them. Much of this understanding is transferable to supervision.

Supervision is a skill set that can be learned and practised. Theoretical knowledge of ethics, regulations and administrative responsibilities is essential, but it is not enough on its own. If you have taken a course that focused primarily on these foundations, consider adding supervision of supervision to deepen your learning. If you are thinking about training, look for a program that includes an experiential component, perhaps case studies or opportunities to practise supervisory conversations. It is just like when you started as a therapist: there is the theory, and then there is the practice.

Becoming a supervisor is not simply about doing more of what you already do as a therapist. It also means developing a different professional identity and learning to hold a different kind of responsibility. But it’s manageable if you find the approach that works best for you. With the right preparation, practice and support, you can find your own way into this rewarding aspect of professional life.

Photo by Sabine Cox with some AI clean-up.